Another
week down and another book in our Harry Potter readalong has ended.
This one is particularly heart wrenching as we are introduced to Messrs.
Moony, Padfoot, Wormtail, and Prongs. Here are a few of our thoughts on
Book Three...
M:
This book is frequently labelled a turning point in the series; while
the first two installments are by no means all sunshine and roses,
Prisoner of Azkaban lacks even the semblance of lightheartedness found
within the first two books. I feel like we get traces of it in places
like Hogsmead, but the specter of the dementors pervades almost ever
section of the novel.
V: I think it's funny that this is your least favorite book.
It's my third favorite, and this one (along with maybe book 4) seems to
be most people's favorite. Sirius and Lupin are such beloved characters,
and people adore this book often for that reason alone. It's
interesting to see how different people approach the series.
It's funny that you mention the parent thing. I've been thinking about
that too, but I think Lupin has a pretty decent reason for never
discussing James in detail. Since it's well-known that James and Sirius
were best friends, and Sirius is on the loose and considered by all to be
a mass murderer, it wouldn't really be the most prudent thing for Lupin
to discuss that he was friends with James, and therefore Sirius. I'm
sure people know they were friends, but as Lupin is already distrusted
among Wizard-kind, I can understand him taking the precaution of
distancing himself a little from those ties to such a notorious
criminal.
As for people like McGonagall, they probably just haven't thought
about it. Harry never asks about his parents (most likely a trained
reflex from 11 years with the "no-questions" Dursleys), and I don't
think most people realize how little he knows about them. Dumbledore is
the only one who seems to recognize Harry's hunger for information, and
just about every time he is able to sit and have a conversation with
Harry, he tells Harry more about his parents.
What I found interesting in this book is how it offers the barest
hints of information that will become vital later in the series. For
instance (without spoiling anything), we get mention of Professor
Trelawney having made a previous prediction, as well as the backstory of
James and co at school. We also get quite a bit of backstory on Snape,
or at least the threads of it, which becomes quite important later on.
Even the idea of the dementors not being entirely underMinistry control
is mentioned very briefly. The foreshadowing in Chamber of Secrets was
incredibly obvious to someone who knows the end of the series, but the
hints in this book are way more subtle and easier to miss.
A couple of my favorite things about this book: 1) Lupin's constant
sass. He does it politely and with a smile, and it's hilarious. 2) The
Quidditch Cup. I'm really glad it took Gryffindor three books to win the
Cup, because it really built up the tension for that final match
against Slytherin. Especially have played and watched Muggle Quidditch, I
completely understand the tension involved in the scoring before
catching the snitch and everything. 3) Lee Jordan's commentary. I simply
love it.
I was most bothered by Harry and Ron's quite unkind treatment of
Hermione in this book. I know they're only 13, but what did you think
about that??
M: At one point after discovering Lupin
went to school with his father Harry says "you must have know Sirius
Black as well" and Lupin replies "I thought I did." Oh, that part breaks
my heart. It does seem that it would have been both difficult and
dangerous for Lupin to talk about his old friends. And with Sirius
escaping and having Harry thrust into his life you can imagine that the
emotions he had been coping with for the last twelve years would be
overwhelming. I think this is true for Snape as well...I don't want to
delve too far into Snape's backstory considering we don't learn much
about it until later in the series, but the resentment and despair of
his entire life is personified in Harry Potter then exacerbated by the
escape of Black and the position of Lupin at Hogwarts. And he still
brews Lupin's much needed potion! I've said before that I am not a Snape
apologist, but I am a bit more sympathetic to him this time around.
As for the trio's many bumps in the road this year I'll say
this, I have two siblings (one older and one younger) and I can say from
experience that with three close friends alliances build and fall
constantly but the three of you are always a unit. When it matters Ron,
Hermione, and Harry all come together. It makes sense for them to have
falling outs once in a while. Plus, the tension between Ron and Hermione
is building. They are weirded out by their attraction to one another
and it comes out in their preteen state as anger sometimes.
And finally, I take your joy in Lupin's sass and raise you
McGonagall throwing major shade at Trelawney. The Christmas dinner scene
is fantastic.V: Oh I certainly understand the fighting and bickering between friends who almost resemble siblings in a way. I grew up with two brothers myself (also one older and one younger...imagine that), so it's understandable that they fight. It would be unbelievable if they didn't. But Harry and particularly Ron seemed to be just mean to Hermione in this book. The poor girl has so much going on, she's stressed to the max and clearly trying to do more than she can handle (which is kind of nice to read, as it reinforces Hermione's humanity), and she really was just trying to help. They kind of abandon her at her most vulnerable point in the series so far, and Ron especially is kind of cruel about it a couple of times. I just found myself feeling really bad for Hermione and being quite angry at Harry and Ron for their poor treatment of her. I know Hermione didn't exactly start off the series with friends, but the loneliness of being friendless is completely different from the loneliness of your friends ignoring you. I feel for her.
You make an excellent point. McGonagall got some fantastic bits of
snark in this one. I also love her Quidditch rivalry with Snape. It's
hilarious to me that these two very dignified teachers get really caught
up in Quidditch.
M: I do think Ron and Harry's treatment of Hermione is meant to be a big deal. Hagrid even talks to them about it, and frankly I love that Hermione goes to Hagrid with her troubles. He really is the most maternal character.
I'll end out thoughts on Azkaban here with something we haven't spoken about at all - the films. Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban is in my opinion the best film in the series even if it isn't one of my favorite books, and as Victoria has pointed out on Tumblr it is the film in which Harry looks the most like...well, Harry! That reminds me, are you keeping up with us on Twitter, Tumblr,
and Facebook?
No comments:
Post a Comment